Search
New gray New England townhomes beside a landscaped common green and pine woods in late autumn.

What Redbrook's Last New Homes Cost Next to Plymouth's 2026 Sales

"The Story of Redbrook is almost Complete." That is the heading A.D. Makepeace's sales site puts over The Preserve on the Agawam, the E.J. Pontiff neighborhood it calls Redbrook's "second to last." If you're comparing South Plymouth with the rest of town, that line matters because only two kinds of new home are still for sale in the village. Each is priced against a different benchmark.

The two kinds point in opposite directions. The new townhomes are priced almost exactly where recorded 2026 sales on the same streets closed. The new single-family homes are priced well above what a typical Plymouth single-family home sold for this fall. At Redbrook, the type of home you choose sets the price far more than its being new.

Two products left on the price sheet

As of early November 2026, the developer's listings showed four homes in The Preserve, at 18, 29, 6 and 8 Preservation Way. Asking prices ran from $889,900 to $949,900. E.J. Pontiff designs and builds them. The plan names are Hawthorn, Magnolia, Magnolia II, Spruce, White Oak, White Pine and White Pine II, and the developer describes the White Oak as a one-story cottage.

The second product is the attached townhomes Whitman Homes builds in the North Village. Redbrook's townhome page says only two remain. The November 2 listings show 11 Trumpet Vine Lane at $614,900 and 95 Sunflower Way at $616,900.

That puts roughly $275,000 to $335,000 between the cheapest new townhome and the cheapest new single-family home. Once you set the two products beside what has actually sold in Plymouth this year, that gap means more than the label "new construction."

The townhome streets already have a 2026 price record

The Plymouth Independent publishes Plymouth's recorded sales every month. Between January and mid-August 2026, its lists show nine sales on Daisy Lane and Sunflower Way, two of Redbrook's townhome streets:

  • 21 Daisy Lane, $620,000, January 30
  • 56 Sunflower Way, $789,900, March 10, and 26 Daisy Lane, $620,000, March 31
  • 3 Daisy Lane, $565,000, May 21, and 20 Daisy Lane, $617,000, May 22
  • 1 Sunflower Way, $617,500, June 9, and 27 Daisy Lane, $575,000, June 23
  • 29 Daisy Lane, $625,000, August 10, and 23 Sunflower Way, $575,000, August 14

Eight of the nine closed between $565,000 and $625,000. The two new townhomes now listed, at $614,900 and $616,900, fall inside that range. Four of the recorded sales, at $617,000, $617,500 and $620,000 twice, are within a few thousand dollars of today's new asking prices.

The monthly lists record only address, date and price, so they don't say which closings were a builder's first sale and which were resales. What they do show is the range that townhomes on these two streets have closed in this year, and the new units are asking prices inside it. If you want a Redbrook townhome, the asking price on a new unit gives you little reason to pass over an existing one, or the other way around. Finishes, timing and the unit itself carry more weight.

Plymouth's townwide condominium numbers point the same way. The Massachusetts Association of Realtors puts the year-to-date Plymouth condo median through October 2026 at $625,000. A new Redbrook townhome costs about what an ordinary attached home in Plymouth has sold for this year.

The Preserve is priced against a different number

The single-family side tells a different story. MAR's October 2026 Plymouth report shows a median single-family sale price of $797,900 for the month, up 14% from $699,900 in October 2025. The year-to-date single-family median through October is $720,000. MAR's own footnote warns that a single month can swing on a small sample, so the year-to-date figure is the steadier comparison.

Against that $720,000 year-to-date median, The Preserve's asking prices are about $170,000 to $230,000 higher. Against October's $797,900 alone, the gap is about $92,000 to $152,000. A townhome buyer pays close to the town's typical price. A Preserve buyer pays a clear premium over what most Plymouth single-family buyers have spent in 2026.

The Pinehills, the other planned community in town, gives a second reference point. On November 12, 2026, its listings included single-family homes from $749,000 to $1,550,000, along with Whitman Homes townhomes from $689,500 to $827,900. The Preserve's range sits inside the Pinehills single-family spread. Redbrook's Whitman townhomes are about $75,000 below the lowest Pinehills Whitman townhome listed that day.

The market around Redbrook has loosened

Since the premium on a Preserve home is measured against the rest of Plymouth, the rest of Plymouth matters. MAR counted 188 single-family homes for sale in Plymouth in October 2026, compared with 146 a year earlier. Months of supply rose from 2.7 to 3.2, and cumulative days on market rose from 51 to 71. New listings in October were 89, up from 70.

The Plymouth Independent's October 22 market report found the same shift by counting a single week. That week 172 single-family homes were listed in town, 39% more than the 124 in the same week of 2025. The paper described buyer leverage as improving, with prime properties still the exception.

Sellers who did close in October still received 99.3% of their original list price on average. So prices haven't softened, but time and choice have opened up. For a Preserve buyer, that means a wider set of existing Plymouth single-family homes to weigh against a new build this winter, and more time to decide. For a townhome buyer, the comparison is mostly within Redbrook, because the new units and the recorded sales are already priced so close together.

What every Redbrook address carries each month

Most of the Plymouth homes you'll compare don't come with these monthly costs. Redbrook has a Landowners Association and its own water and wastewater billing. The most recent fee sheet on Redbrook's site is dated 2022. For single-family and twin homes, it lists a Landowners Association fee of $180 per month and water and wastewater charges of $109.71 per month before usage, for a stated total of $289.71 plus water consumption. The $109.71 is a $49.71 water base charge plus wastewater at $2 per day. The 2022 sheet is a few years old, so confirm current amounts for any specific address before you compare monthly budgets. These figures are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and it's wise to review your own numbers with your lender or another qualified professional.

Monthly carrying costs like these weigh more heavily at the townhome price point, where the purchase price has little room left to negotiate.

The village center is already built

Unlike a subdivision still waiting on its amenities, Redbrook already has its village center. Redbrook's site lists Black Lantern Tavern, Rise and Grind Bakery and Cafe and Sweet Grace & Co. Ice Cream. Its lifestyle page adds the Old Colony YMCA, Beth Israel Lahey Health Primary Care, Long Pond Physical Therapy and a Rockland Trust ATM and lending office around Redbrook Square. The developer's townhome pages name The Village Green, The Meeting House, the Community Garden, the Fun Yard, a dog park and walking trails. The lifestyle page describes an events calendar of concerts, movie nights and nature walks. Halstead Plymouth, the rental community inside Redbrook, advertises 16 miles of nature trails, five ponds and reservoirs, kayak and canoe launches and a dog beach.

Whether you buy on Preservation Way or Daisy Lane, you get the same village. That's one more reason the price gap between the two home types is mostly about the house and lot.

What comes after The Preserve

Redbrook is close to its full size. In 2025 the Plymouth Independent reported that the development had more than 1,000 single-family homes, condos and apartments, and that a Makepeace official said it would reach 1,288 units when complete. With The Preserve described as the second to last neighborhood, only one more Redbrook neighborhood remains after it.

Cranberry Commons is a separate project, planned as 62 affordable apartments for seniors at 234–240 Wareham Road and built by the Grantham Group. It received a state funding award in February 2025, and a December 2025 state notice set out the next federal funding step.

Quick answers

Is a new Redbrook townhome priced above recent sales on the same streets?

Not by much. The two new Whitman townhomes listed in November ask $614,900 and $616,900. Eight of the nine sales recorded on Daisy Lane and Sunflower Way between January and mid-August 2026 closed between $565,000 and $625,000.

How do The Preserve's prices compare with Plymouth overall?

The Preserve's November asking prices of $889,900 to $949,900 are about $170,000 to $230,000 above Plymouth's year-to-date single-family median of $720,000 through October 2026.

Is there more to choose from in Plymouth this fall?

Yes. Single-family inventory in October 2026 was 188 homes, up from 146 a year earlier, and cumulative days on market rose to 71 from 51.

If you're deciding between one of the last Preserve homes, a Redbrook townhome and an existing home elsewhere in Plymouth, let's set the asking prices, recorded sales and monthly costs for your shortlist side by side with Shana Lundell. You'll find more on how she works with buyers on the buyers page and on new construction under developments. Let's Connect.

Work With Shana

She is proud to have over 100 five-star client testimonials that rave about her positive, professional, responsive, and authentic approach to real estate service. Love where you live. Live where you love.

FOLLOW ME